For most of human history, there was one thing about music you couldn’t change: if you wanted to hear it, someone had to be playing it, right there and then. There was no pausing, no replaying or no addition to queue-ing. How long you listened to music depended on how long the people performing it felt like it. And when that last note of the night echoed away, it was gone for good. The fact that nowadays we carry essentially every song ever written in a device that’s about the same size as a few folded pieces of sheet music is nothing short of absurd.
But how? No way did we go from giant orchestra’s to Spotify in a single night. It’s a long road, one that has a lot of horns, wax, hot metal, magnetic ribbons and some fancy silver discs here and there. And of course, the thing that almost destroyed an industry. From the top!
Before anyone really figured out how to “capture” sound, there were a grand total of two ways to preserve music. One was the beloved notation. Written sheet music is by no means a new discovery and has existed for centuries. But sheet music is just a part of the process, it’s a recipe not the actual meal. It can tell a musician what to play, absolutely, but it doesn’t really tell you what the performance actually sounded like. Two people reading the same exact bar (or measure if you’re American) could sound completely different.
Then came musical boxes, though it’s nothing like the small ones we can get nowadays. Before we get into their history, what are they? Well a musical box is well, a box, with a spinning cylinder covered in tiny pins that basically “plucked” a metal comb, and this would cause them to play a tune. A simple and short tune that repeated, but nonetheless portable music! However, the first “musical box” was by no means portable. Created by a trio of Persian inventors in the 9th century, what’s often called the earliest known mechanical instrument was a hydro powered organ that automatically played interchangeable cylinders. And these cylinders with pins on them where basically the main form of storing “playable” music for a while. As Fowler states in “the museum of music” (1967), “Cylinder(s) with raised pins remained the the basis device to store and reproduce music mechanically until the latter half of the 19th century.”
And in the late 1800s, specifically 1895, an American inventor by the name of Edwin S. Votey created what’s known as a “Pianola”. A pianola or a player piano is basically an automatic piano. It used perforated paper tools to play keys automatically, Votey’s design specially using foot petals to drive a pneumatic motor. However neither of these are actual recordings. The musical box is but an instrument that can only play one specific tune, and the Player piano just took instructions to recreate music, it wasn’t a true “recording”.
Nobody really worked out how to “store” the sound. That was a loottt harder to figure out.
The Phonoautograph: Recording!
Okay so to start off: I lied. Kinda. In 1857, a French inventor named Édouard Léon Scott De Martinville created a machine called the Phonoautograph. The Phonoautograph was a device that could store music. It had an acoustic trumpet that funnelled sound onto a vibrating membrane, which was attached to a boar’s bristle that it barely grazed a thin layer of lampblack (soot based pain basically) that was on top of a sheet of glass. The glass would be slid horizontally at a speed of 1 meter per second while someone spoke into the trumpet, causing the membrane to vibrate and to trace figures.
Now that might seem like a bizarre way to do things but it’s not too far off from how we hear things. In our ears, we turn sound waves into electrical signals that our brain interprets as sound. In the Phonautograph it converted sound into visible lines.
Now here’s the “kinda” part. The thing worked brilliantly, however it could not play anything back. Édouard Léon Scott De Martinville never intended it to. He just thought people would look back at the “squiggles” and study them. And we did! It took until 2008, but researchers scanned the soot-covered recording and finally heard what was captured. Among them is a recording of someone in 1860 singing a part of a French folk song, and it’s one of the oldest known recordings of a human voice!
Okay so the kinda part was a lie too. It didn’t actually take us until 2008 to hear any recorded piece of audio, it took until 1877, courtesy of the ever-so-famous Thomas Edison, who built the Phonograph. The first edition of this device was basically just recording onto essentially tinfoil that was wrapped around a cylinder. You spoke or sang into a horn that vibrated a needle and dented a foil. You then reversed the process by running the needle through the dented foil to essentially hear a very scratchy echo of what you said. The first recording was apparently Edison singing “Mary Had a Little Lamb”
Tinfoils didn’t really last all that long, so the cylinders were then changed to wax, which not only held up better, but also could be played a few more times. And in the late 1880’s came a German inventor by the name of Emile Berliner (He was born in Hanover who called the jam filled pastry a “krapfen”. So no, he was not named after a pastry.) who took a slightly different approach with the gramophone. He used a flat disc instead of cylinders. Why wouldn’t you? Discs are cheaper to make and they can stack, meaning you could essentially “stamp” copies instead of recording each one individually.
This branch of evolution basically caused a cat and dog war between the discs and the cylinders. And well considering how most music in the 1900’s were recorded in vinyl, you can guess who won. They essentially became the shaper of recorded music during most of the 20th century.
(Fun fact, the first and only recording of Otto Von Bismark happened during this battle between the two mediums. In 1889, a representative of Edison helped Von Bismark record himself onto a wax cylinder where Bismark famously said a few things. Two things are to note, one being the opening to La Marseille and advice to his son. The advice basically went “don’t overwork and don’t overdrink” which was ironic coming from the guy who had glasses of wine with every meal)
The records that basically dominated the first half of the 20th century were made out of shellac compounds. Shellac is a type of natural plastic in a way. It was a very brittle material and it was made from a resin secreted by lac insects. The discs themselves were a mix of Shellac and some sort of organic filler, generally slate dust, wood flour and carbon bleach (Fun fact, slate dust also acted as not only an abrasive filler but also like literally sandpaper to shape and sharpen the playback needle). These spun at about 78 revolutions per minute, and the standard 10-inch discs could only hold about 3 minutes of music per side.
3 minutes is kind of a big deal. For decades anything an artist made that a record company wanted to sell had to fit inside that window, so songs were trimmed and arranged to be about three minutes long. This habit stuck looong after anyone even needed it to as to this day it is the general length of songs. A limit of a physical medium basically shaped how an entire art form is created.
Early recordings also happened acoustically, without much electrical guidance. Performers basically had to huddle around a giant horn and play or sing into it. Quiet instruments were not really that audible so instruments like the violins were modified to have horns on them (called Stroh Violins). And singers basically had to yell-sing (belt). Then in 1925, microphones and other electrical recording measures were added, which let recordings be able to capture a far wider range of sound. From delicate whispers to full blown orchestras, everything could be heard. Singers now had the ability to be subtle.
Around the same time, radio came along, causing mass panic in the music business. This was because instead of buying songs, you could just tune into a radio station that was playing that song. Radio wasn’t really new by this point. It was first described by a Scottish mathematician called James Maxwell in 1878. And by the 1900s , it was used for military and diplomatic texting, the radio we are familiar with didn’t come until 1920. During WW1, Reginald Fessenden, a Canadian-American electrical engineer, managed to achieve AM (amplitude modulation) radio telephony. Which allowed audio to be transmitted over radio. On November 2nd, 1920, under the call sign KDKA the first public radio broadcast was created in Pittsburg. It broadcasted the 1920 US elections.
Record sales took a major hit in the 1920’s and the Great Depression made it far worse. However, in the grand scheme of things, radio and records learned to need each other. Radio turns songs into hits, and hits sold records. This relationship almost defines the music industry for the rest of the century.
This was essentially the next leap. Using magnetic materials to store things comes from the late 1800s, before being cemented as a plausible medium in 1898. A Danish engineer named Valdemar Poulsen created a telegraphone, which recorded data onto steel wire. But this wasn't a major form of storage until the 1930s when the company known as Allgemeine Elektrizitäts-Gesellschaft or AEG created the magnetophon, which recorded onto plastic tape coated with magnetic particles.
After World War II, an American soldier named Jack Mullin discovered some of these German machines and brought them back home. Their sound quality was shockingly good. Mullin then caught the attention of Bing Crosby, who was in simple terms, lazy. He got tired of performing his radio show live and wanted to pre-record it. Ampex then created American tape machines, and music wasn’t really the same after that.
Why? Why does a strip of plastic change everything? Editing. You can cut that piece of plastic and tape back together. Fix a wrong note just by splicing in a better take. Run it backwards! Run it sideways! You can even record on top of your earlier recordings!
That last little trick, recording on top of earlier recordings, led to multitrack recording. Les Paul, a guitarist and an inventor experimented with layering different recordings on top of each other, and in the 50s Ampex made a special 8 track machine for him. So instead of recording a full band in a single take, you capture them one by one. The drums, then the base, then the guitar and the vocals. Then you mix them later. Records stopped being documentation of a performance in a way but became constructed objects. Later, bands like the Beatles pushed this idea to the extreme, using limited four track machines and bouncing tracks together to create sounds that no one could create live.
About the same time, stereo was gaining popularity. The idea was first patented by a British engineer, Alan Blumlein, in 1931, but stereo records didn’t reach the public until the late 50s. Instead of one channel of sound, you got two, which meant instruments could appear on the left, the right, or in the middle. Record could suddenly feel like a space you were standing inside of.
By the end of the 40’s, shellac was getting old. In 48’, Columbia Records introduced the long playing record, or the LP, designed by a team of engineers led by Peter Goldmark. It was made out of polyvinyl chloride (PVC, or Vinyl for short) spun a lot slower at 33 ⅓ rpm and could hold about 20 minutes of music per side. A year later, a rival company called RCA victor unveiled the 7 inch 45 rpm single.
For a long time, these two formats were essentially in direct competition, which I personally refer to as the “war of the speeds,” until the industry figured out that they didn’t really need to fight. They did different jobs, after all. The 45 was for singles: short, cheap and perfect for jukeboxes and teenagers with pocket money. The LP was for longer works, and over time artists started imagining albums as its own form of art, not just a collection but one with a beginning and an end and a middle, complete with cover art. Without the LP, more conceptual albums like The Dark Side of The Moon by Pink Floyd wouldn’t really make sense as an idea.
Up till the 50’s listening to music was something you did at home, near a large piece of Fortnite (may that be an amp or a speaker). Then things slowly started to shrink. The transistor radio came in 1954, and for the first time you carried music in your pocket! A gigantic pocket yes, but a pocket nonetheless.
In 1963, Phillips, a famous Dutch company, created the compact cassette. Magnetic tape in a small plastic case. This allowed music to be played and recorded on something not just cheap, but also tiny. This gave us mixtapes, a cherry picked and hand play list that essentially functioned as whatever you wanted it to, may that be a love letter, a mood or just a very very petty message. Right alongside the cassette came the 8-track tape, marketed hard for Bill Lear, an American inventor. The 8-track cartridges were popular in cars in the late 60s and 70s before cassette essentially knocked it out the map.
Then came the mystical, wonderful year of 1979. It originally just started off as a modified pressman, a recorder made specially for journalists. The pressman was compact and it worked brilliantly. And it was then modified to playback the recordings. After people complimented the quality of it, the company decided to go all in. This extremely bad retelling is the story of none other than the Sony Walkman. The Walkman was a small cassette player with headphones. And to say it changed how people related and listened to music completely is nothing short of an understatement. Before this, listening to music using headphones meant you sat down at your home, plugged it into your home amp, played a vinyl or anything and listened to it. Now, for the first time, it moved with you. Even though headphones provided you with that private music listening experience, you were still confined. But the Walkman changed everything. You could just do whatever you wanted, and still listen to it. For once, you could listen to music and take a walk in a park.
Around the 70s and 80s, engineers started trying to convert sound into digital information. Instead of grooves or a magnetic pattern, which physically mirrors the sound wave, a digital recording measures the waves thousands of times per second and stores each measurement as a number. Play the numbers back in order and viola (yes, that's spelled correctly; it's a pun) you rebuilt the sound.
In 82’ Sony and Phillips launched the compact disc. Also known as the CD, it stored music as tiny microscopic little pits, read by a laser, and it came with big promises: No hissing, no pops and no wear that came from a needle dragging through a groove. One of the first ever CD’s sold to the public was Billy Joel’s 52nd Street. A CD can store about 74 minutes of music. The story goes that this was done so it could fit Beethoven’s Ninth symphony on one single disc. Whether that was true or just a part of the rumor mill, that capacity stuck, and CD’s became the dominant music format by the 90’s, quietly killing the cassette.
Digital audio meant one other thing: audio could be copied perfectly, edited on computers and stored without degrading. That last part kinda matters a lot.
A CD sure holds a lot of data, doesn’t it? It’s great for sound quality and absolutely terrible for anything you wanted to send over the internet back then. So, in the early 90’s, researchers in Germany, led by Karlheinz Brandenburg at the Fraunhofer institute worked out a compression method that threw away sounds that human ears wouldn’t notice. Basically, keep the essentials. They tested it with a lot of songs, but also Suzanne Vega’s “Tom’s Diner”, a quiet acapella song. Because if the compression could truly handle a voice that clean, it could probably handle most things. The result was the MP3, which shark music files to about a tenth of their original size with only a modest loss in quality.
Suddenly a song could be sent over the internet in mere minutes. In 99, a teenager named Shawn Fanning launched Napster, a website that allowed people to share music with each other. Millions of people quickly used it to download music for free, and after getting sued, Napster was shut down in 2001. But it was too late, Pandora had already opened the box.
Before we get to the iPod, we’re gonna talk about MPman. MPman, aside from sounding like a knockoff Pepsi man and having a mascot that looks absolutely terrifying, is the name of the first mp3 player to ever be released. Originally created by the South Korean company SaeHan in 98’, it was later imported to North America and other parts of the world by other companies like Eiger.
Then comes literally the only MP3 or portable audio device that matters. The iPod. Originally released in 2001, with a claim for storing up to a 1000 songs, followed by the iTunes Store is 2003. The iPod was so dominant that in terms of market share, the product that came in second was considered a commercial failure. (The Microsoft Zune, if you're curious) Of course other brands made MP3 players, such as Phillips, and the walkman still existed; Creative, Microsoft, HP, Dell, Lego, Nerf, literally anyone you could think of probably made an MP3 player. However, none really held a candle up to the success of the iPod. The general rule of thumb was: If it ain’t an iPod, people didn't buy it.
Then came Spotify in 2008. Released in Sweden, it came with a different idea: why own your music? You basically just rent access to gigantic libraries. Today, streaming is by far the most popular method of listening to music and the physical object has become optional and less common. But not gone!!!
(not actually talking about the movie released in 1984, it’s more in general about instruments that went electric)
The same time recording was revolving, so did the instruments. In the late 30s electric guitars appeared, because a standard acoustic just simply couldn't compete with the volume of a big band. The Hammond organ also came around the same time, a tone wheel electric driven instrument that was not only smaller, but also cheaper than a proper pipe organ.
In 64’ Robert Moog unveiled the Moog synthesiser, which generated sounds from electrical circuits rather than physical strings or pipes. Early synths were gigantic, temperamental and could at most play one note a time. But they did open an entire new palette of sounds. And in the 80’s, with the introduction of MIDI (Musical Instrument Digital Interface), we were able to let electronic instruments and computers talk to each other, and sampling aloud producers to build new things out of snippets of other recordings. Hip-hop, electronic music and modern pop all grew out of this.
Then of course, as with most things, software took over. Digital Audio Workstations meant an entire studio, that was the size of rooms and costing an absolute fortune could now simply fit on your lap(top). And in 98’ came auto tune. Originally meant for subtly correcting slightly off key singing, was pushed to its extreme by some artists. An early example is Cher’s “Believe”, using it to create a more robotic vocal effect. The use of auto tune is still somewhat of a grey area in terms of modern music, as some don't mind it, and others consider it as a lack of skill or disrespect to the art.
If you just listen a bit closer, the whole history of music recording is just one giant tug of war between three things: Quality, conscience and ownership.
Early records didn’t have the greatest of quality but they did offer convenience, they could be mass produced after all. Tape gave us amazing editing power but in the end, it was too giddily. The cassette and the walkman traded some of the power and quality for portability. The CD offered cleaner sound and “convenience” in the same package. MP3 sacrificed some audio fidelity for the convenience of carrying everything with you, and finally with streaming, we took convenience so far that ownership was quietly removed from the equation.
And in a twist everyone saw coming: The return of the Vinyl. Humans love physical media, and the same way Polaroids and instant film photography is back, Vinyl has started its rise again. In recent years, Vinyls have even outsold CDs in terms of revenue. Even though we can basically stream everything anywhere, we choose to buy this big heavy scratchable disc that can be broken and carefully dropping a needle on it. Convenience might’ve won the battle, but not the war. Humans see music as art and treat it as such, so why not improve your experience of listening to music as well?
The new formats promised us that it was better than the last in some way, and all of them had to give up something else to get there. It’s still probably going on, somewhere someone doing research to see how they can make streaming better. It won’t stop. Not until we start uploading things to ourselves and just avoid pressing play at all.
(Press play on these ol’ recordings)
The Recording on the Phonautograph:
https://youtu.be/WpXNqdEUhWY?is=X_6KlcrFZTqohmNl
The recording of Otto Von Bismark